Tend to when schedules are given, he or she is given with twenty four hours of your week one do perhaps not match with this go out whilst during the real history. One example happens in Harry Potter plus the Prisoner from Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney makes reference to 16 Oct given that Friday, though sixteen Oct 1993 was a saturday.
There are also contradictions inside the instructions here. Like, inside Harry Potter in addition to Goblet away from Flames, each other 1 Sep and you will dos September are given since Mondays and you may, during the Harry Potter while the Prisoner off Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is decided for the 20 April, but careful parsing of the text message shows that it might keeps occurred no after than simply March.
In addition to, in Harry Potter while the Cup from Flames they claim that the Winners was basically chosen into Monday 30 October, but 29 Oct is a monday inside the 1994.
In chapter 7 out of Quidditch Through the Many years, they claim that very first Quidditch Globe Cup occured during the 1473. When your championship was kept all couple of years, which problems on the statement from inside the Cup regarding Fire your 1994 Business Glass was the fresh 422nd. If Quidditch From Decades is right, this new 422nd Quidditch Community Mug would indeed fall-in the season 3161, however if Goblet out-of Fire is useful, the original Globe Glass is stored inside 306.
Historical problems [ ]
Whilst the series, with respect to the schedule produced by the latest Chamber off Secrets site, is set about 1990s, the collection often seems as though it’s place in the new late nineties to help you middle-2000s, around concurrent on guide of the guides. When you look at the Harry Potter additionally the Half-Bloodstream Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a masculine pronoun to mention for the “predecessor” of Finest Minister of your Uk. With regards to the more than timeline, this would take place in the summertime off 1996, if the Prime Minister are John Major, whose quick predecessor is a female (‘s the reason first meeting with Fudge, the publication states the newest election, but Major was not initially decided and only got more than immediately after Thatcher resigned.
You will be able, however unlikely, you to definitely Fudge would be writing on a very distant ancestor, because Thatcher grabbed workplace just before Fudge supposedly turned into Minister to own Magic. (Even if one can possibly consider a situation where Fudge is actually delegated because of the Minister to own Miracle to meet up with with the Prime Minister as he, Fudge, was a student in an inferior office.) On the other hand, the newest identity and you can reputation of the top Minister represented appears to significantly more directly matches compared to Tony Blair than simply off John Big. A post throughout the Daily Post notes one Rowling was romantic towards then-Chancellor of your own Exchequer Gordon Brown (usually seen as a competitor in order to Blair’s frontrunners of the Work Group, exactly who been successful your and you can turned Prime Minister), and that she has been wanting to inform you Blair’s bad front. In the event the courses was devote sync having publication time regarding Philosopher’s Brick, up coming which experience would occur in 2002 (immediately after Blair turned Finest Minister).
not, it actually was afterwards stated that twenty-two November are a friday, that it was in 1994
An equivalent situation pertains to Nicolas Flamel, who was mentioned to be 665 during the time of the new earliest guide, but Nicolas Flamel try a bona-fide historic shape and you can would not reach that years up to 1996, within big date the original guide are authored. The latest rebuttal for it is that the time the brand new “real” Nicolas Flamel was created cannot correspond with the brand new Nicolas Flamel out-of Harry Potter.
Another type of problem can be found off Rubeus Hagrid’s period due to the fact Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s created regarding the show that Hagrid obtained you to definitely position contained in this a few years regarding their expulsion out of school in 1942. But in you to definitely scene out-of Harry Potter together with Goblet out of Flames, Molly Weasley reminisces in the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper seem to overlap having Molly’s many years at school, it looks impractical one to she recalls a previous gamekeeper. Yet not, it will be possible you to definitely Hagrid don’t end up being a beneficial gamekeeper instantaneously immediately following are expelled, but alternatively become because the Ogg’s secretary. It is plausible as the when Harry thinks which he will end up being expelled to possess flying on the broomstick in the place of permission inside the first 12 months, he secret if he’d be allowed to stick to as the Hagrid’s secretary.
